African religion, climate change, and knowledge systems. The pragmatics of defining religion in a multicultural world dr. Dreams of passage an objectrelational perspective on a. Both men lived in an age when 5for the problems in defining religion, see jan g. The declared adherents of the indigenous religion are very conservative, resisting the. The problem of the definition of religion, in jan platvoet and arie molendijk, eds.
In religion and non religion among australian aboriginal peoples, edited by james l. Religion, science, and space exploration from a non. Contexts, concepts and contests 1999 especially 260261. Others, such as wilfred cantwell smith, have tried to correct a perceived judeochristian and western bias in the. The conceptualization of religion in relational psychoanalysis, in. Religion as the transmission of an authoritative tradition. On essentialism and real definitions of religion journal. Platvoet puts it, african religions, as a group or type of human religion, are the oldest of humankind. Religion and the individual orca cardiff university. It has become the largest of the worlds religions and, geographically, the most widely diffused. Oxford dictionaries defines religion as the belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power, especially a personal god or gods. Pdf clarifying the definition of religion under english law. The need and possibility of defining religion have been challenged, but such.
Defining religion is a notoriously intractable subject among scholars. The new age movement represents the historically innovative phenomenon of a secular type of religion based upon a radically private symbolism. By religion, then, i understand a propitiation or conciliation of powers superior to man which are believed to direct and control the course of nature and of human life james george frazer, the golden bough. This thesis is developed against the background of a threepart definition of religion, according to which religion in general may manifest in the form of either religions or. Ucc library and ucc researchers have made this item openly. Natural scientists, too, have explored the idea of how religion and science might be fundamentally opposed dawkins 2008 as well as how religion and science might intersect margenau 1984. It makes a plea for phenomenologically wellinformed research on real forms of religion and spirituality, from. Thirty years or so ago, specialists in philosophy of religion were a rare breed. This is an open access document downloaded from orca, cardiff.
Only after having defined the belief can we define the rite 1995, 34. Victoria harrison university of glasgow this is an archived version of the pragmatics of defining religion in a multicultural world, published in the international journal for philosophy of religion 59 2006. Purchase instant access pdf download and unlimited online access. In its most recent episode, initiated by robert segals defense of. Law, anthropology, and the definition of religion 1995 6 seton hall constitutional law journal 23 70. Nov, 2018 the volume has contributions from scholars in philosophy of religion, the comparative study of religions, anthropology of religion, sociology of religion and psychology of religion. Jun 25, 2019 a good example of a narrow definition being too narrow is the common attempt to define religion as belief in god, effectively excluding polytheistic religions and atheistic religions while including theists who have no religious belief system. Most recently, i proposed a reductive definition of religion, a. On essentialism and real definitions of religion journal of.
This contribution to a collective volume on the problem of how to define religion is con ceived from the perspective of the comparative study of religions. Patterns and prospects of a centurylong quest the pragmatics of defining religion. Defining religion and finding ways to assess it in individual lives has long challenged psychologists of religion. The page numbers of the original publication are indicated between square brackets and are set in bold.
Defining religious ritual will come to first step to. In this book i do not attempt the perilous task of defining philosophy of religion. The pragmatics of defining religion contexts, concepts. Learn about the history of christianity, its doctrines, and the major christian traditions. Sep 04, 2020 this conclusion is unsurprising given the fact that defining religion continues to be a subject of intense debate in academia, where there are competing sociological and phenomenological approaches see siding jensen 2019.
It is a religion that is practised by living men and women. Definition of religion jan platvoet the problem of definition is a central issue, involving not only the concepts within the field of study but also the nature of the field itself. Law and the art of defining religion ecclesiastical law. As the literal word of god, the quran makes known the will of god, to which humans must surrender lending the name islam, meaning surrender.
Among the main impulses for this trend, we can name a paradigmatic shift from the secularization paradigm approaching non religion in modern societies as a norm, while seeing religious phenomena as representing a problem, to alternative perspectives that problematize the. It has chapters on the polemics of defining religion in modern contexts, the history of the concept of religion, and the methodology of its definition. Oct 11, 2017 modernity, which has been associated with development, is often associated with new ideas and has been linked with christianity on the basis that, as j. The pragmatics of defining religion is a multidisciplinary volume on the problem of the definition of religion with chapters on the polemics of defining religion in modern contexts, the history of the concept of religion, the methodology of. At first, openended questionnaires were used, but with the advent of modern statistical methods, a succession of religiosity scales was developed. Hill 1973, 2 this article surveys three traditions in defining religion. Weber and durkheim put forward contrasting views as to the usefulness of a definition of religion. Ritual definition and taxonomy defining what is understood by the term ritual is no easy task, as is evident from grimes 1995. The definition of religion is a controversial and complicated subject in religious studies with scholars failing to agree on any one definition. Drawing on some of the contributions in platvoet and.
In light of this difficulty, this article will follow the example of platvoet 1995. A new approach to the religious traditions of mankind. The volume has contributions from scholars in philosophy of religion, the comparative study of religions, anthropology of religion, sociology of religion and psychology of religion. Urbanrural geographies of aboriginal religious and nonreligious identification. Hermeneutical approaches in psychology of religion 1997. Polkinghorne 1998 and scientists such as stephen j. Defining religion in operational and institutional terms core. Other schools within the mahayana tradition include zen, nichiren and pure land. Neither can pass laws which aid one religion, aid all religions, or prefer one re ligion over another. Brill, 463516 the page numbers of the original publication have been inserted between square brackets and are set in bold. It is not, for example, a discipline distinguishable from others as chemistry is from needlework. Footnote 125 as james wiggins has argued, religious diversity requires the conclusion that the definition of religion must become more expansive and elastic than ever before in human history.
In the definition of religion adopted here, and the overall discussions in this paper. He has published on the traditional religion of the akan of southern ghana, the study of religions in africa, spirit possession, the study of rituals, and the history and methodology. Arnal, definition, in braun and mccutcheon, guide to the study of religion 2000. It proposes an operational definition in the tylorian tradition. This article claims to uncover the core problematics that have made the debate on defining and conceptualizing religion so difficult and argues that this makes it possible to move beyond radical. A wellknown example of a real definition of religion is seen in edward tylors definition of religion as belief in spiritual beings tylor 1970 1871. Molendijk eds, the pragmatics of defining religion. African traditional religion and concepts of development. This thesis is developed against the background of a threepart definition of religion, according to which religion in general may manifest in. Philosophy of religion is now a very flourishing branch of philosophy. The pragmatics of defining religion contexts, concepts and.
Contexts, concepts and contests, brill, leiden, 1999. In this paper, i offer a different approach, one that faces the critique and its effects in the field. We also often use rituals as common practices in religion, so if religion can be separated from nonreligious areas there is a hope for the definition of ritual. A case for preliminary definitions in jan g platvoet and arie l molendijk eds. Dec, 20 beckford, j, the politics of defining religion in secular society in platvoet, j and molendij, a eds, the pragmatics of defining religion. Platvoet describes parrinders work as being decontextualised. The politics of defining religion in secular society. Religious persecution, refugees, and right of asylum. Platvoet, the religion of africa in the historical order, in the study of. Religion is the belief in spiritual beings edward b tylor, primitive culture 2. Platvoet describes the spiritpossession of the akan the bono from the brongahafo region from a. Defining religious ritual will be the first step to defining. An ambitious survey of existing scholarship sponsored by the european union produced in 1999 a tick volume, concluding that academics offer many irreconcilable definitions of religion, and no agreement exists platvoet and molendijk 1999. So, next to rattray and parrinder, a presentday theologian has contributed to the study of the akan religion.
Religions 2020, 11, 397 2 of 10 conflict, independence, dialogue, and integration barbour 1968, 20. In recent years, the sociology of religion has faced an increasing interest in the topic of non religion. Despite the importance of the legal definition of religion. Islam, major world religion that emphasizes monotheism, the unity of god allah in arabic, and muhammad as his final messenger in a series of revelations. Some suggest that we may use heuristic, provisional definitions to get around goldstein et al.
993 1465 1543 435 863 1090 1497 717 1495 982 837 330 1208 1247 516 1269 1274 71 982 117 520 660 997 524 720 726